Language Selection

Get healthy now with MedBeds!
Click here to book your session

Protect your whole family with Orgo-Life® Quantum MedBed Energy Technology® devices.

Advertising by Adpathway

         

 Advertising by Adpathway

Why Man Utd must replace Carrick with the best English manager around

19 hours ago 4

PROTECT YOUR DNA WITH QUANTUM TECHNOLOGY

Orgo-Life the new way to the future

  Advertising by Adpathway

Published Oct 11, 2026, 7:42 PM GMT+1

Tom is a football journalist with over five years of experience, specialising in Premier League reporting, feature writing and transfer analysis, with particular expertise covering Liverpool and Everton.

His work has been featured in The Non-League Paper, Crawley Observer, Sussex Express and The Redmen TV, where he produced features, news and exclusive interviews across all levels of the game.

For Football FanCast, Tom has interviewed a number of respected figures from across football, including Ally McCoist, Philippe Senderos and Chris Waddle. Elsewhere, he has covered the National League South play-off final, Formula E's London E-Prix, Crawley Town and Brighton & Hove Albion's Under-21s.

Tom's expertise lies in analysing transfer developments, explaining what they mean for clubs and supporters, and producing in-depth features on the biggest stories in football. Through years of covering Liverpool and Everton, he has developed an extensive understanding of Merseyside football, both clubs' recruitment strategies and the issues that matter most to their supporters. He has also built strong relationships across the football industry that add valuable context to his reporting and analysis.

Tom also enjoys writing features on the broader challenges facing football, its clubs, players, governing bodies and, most importantly, supporters.

It feels like one of the most repeated lines in Premier League history, but it is once again a fact. After six games, Manchester United have made their worst start to a league season in 40 years.

It has been nothing short of a disaster for Michael Carrick, who is staring down the same barrel that Ole Gunnar Solskjær once faced.

Solskjaer-Man-United-Premier-League

The decision to hire yet another manager following an impressive interim spell always looked likely to end one way. Insanity is simply repeating the same step time and time again and hoping for a different result. Man United have long been on the wrong end of crazy.

Carrick is a man out of his depth and Tottenham Hotspur's late equaliser should act as the latest nail in the coffin of his tenure.

man-utd-second-half-form-table-3000x3000

Man Utd must make brutal Carrick decision ASAP

In the year of 2026, the status of Man United legend should not allow access to the technical area. And that may sound harsh on Carrick after an impressive interim spell, but the facts expose how absurd INEOS' decision was.

Put his club legacy to one side and Carrick's managerial experience stretches into a Middlesbrough spell which never ended in promotion.

Manchester United manager Michael Carrick REUTERS/Peter Cziborra

This is a young manager who always needed more work away from Old Trafford. Going from the sack at Boro to the hot seat at Old Trafford was always an almighty step and, ultimately, a step too far.

There are significant flaws in Carrick's system similar to ones seen under Erik ten Hag and even Ruben Amorim.

As much as the manager refused to admit that his side lacks intensity, the space between his frontline, midfield and backline suggests that Man United simply aren't competing off the ball.

Distance covered in the Premier League

Rank

Team

Matches

Distance per match (km)

1

Arsenal

6

119.4

2

Fulham

6

118.5

3

Brentford

6

117.6

4

Ipswich Town

6

116.0

5

Leeds United

6

115.9

6

Crystal Palace

5

115.2

7

Sunderland

6

115.0

8

Newcastle United

5

114.9

9

AFC Bournemouth

6

114.9

10

Brighton & Hove Albion

6

114.5

11

Hull City

5

114.2

12

Everton

5

113.6

13

Chelsea

6

113.6

14

Tottenham Hotspur

6

112.9

15

Nottingham Forest

5

112.5

16

Manchester United

6

111.9

17

Aston Villa

6

111.7

18

Manchester City

5

111.2

19

Coventry City

5

110.5

20

Liverpool

5

110.3

Only four sides have covered less distance than Man United in the Premier League so far this season and that's a major problem for Carrick. It points to two issues. The first of which is simple - United are simply not physical enough. The second of which is the fact that United are having more possession than last season.

That's the biggest issue for Carrick, who is being exposed as a manager who thrives in transition but cannot cope when asked to control games in possession. And when in charge of arguably the biggest club in England, that will only end one way.

Why Man Utd must hire another English coach to replace Carrick

So where do Man United go from here? Do they tuck their tails between their legs for the umpteenth time, admit they got it wrong and swiftly move on?

Does Sir Jim Ratcliffe ignore ego and make the right decision? Even he, in his usual stubborn self, may have no choice.

The managerial market is perfectly placed to drag United out of the hole they once again find themselves in. Some may say they've been in that hole for over a decade, digging themselves in as a ludicrous attempt to escape.

Managers out of work (September 28th)

This time, however, Eddie Howe has the chance to offer them a hand out of disaster. Reports earlier this week suggested that the owners were 'ready' to bring him to Old Trafford should Carrick receive his marching orders.

The former Newcastle United boss makes perfect sense for the Red Devils. He didn't always operate on a major budget at Newcastle due to PSR constraints, and that will please Ratcliffe, and he majorly overachieved at St James' Park, qualifying for the Champions League and winning the Carabao Cup.

Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe reacts after the match REUTERS/Andrew Boyers

Unlike Carrick, this is a manager full of experience across English football. He transformed Bournemouth, welcomed a new era at Newcastle and can drag United back to glory.

Eddie Howe in the Premier League

Games

369

Wins

140

Draws

81

Defeats

148

In some ways, Howe is similar to Carrick. His Newcastle side always thrived in transition. Anthony Gordon, Alexander Isak and Jacob Murphy provided an excellent trio to do just that like Bruno Fernandes, Bryan Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha do at Old Trafford.

The difference is that Howe can and did adapt at Newcastle. When the Magpies were asked to control games as they stepped into the top six, they outmatched opposition sides on a physical level and had the ability to control.

eddie-howe-newcastle-premier-league

Howe, at his best, managed a side who were deadly going forward and just as good going the other way as Sven Botman and Fabian Schar thrived.

Whilst Jamie Carragher dubbed him the "next England manager", it's Man United who should be first in line to snap up Howe as soon as possible.

Read Entire Article

         

        

HOW TO FIGHT BACK WITH THE 5G  

Protect your whole family with Quantum Orgo-Life® devices

  Advertising by Adpathway