PROTECT YOUR DNA WITH QUANTUM TECHNOLOGY
Orgo-Life the new way to the future Advertising by Adpathway
Image credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Kansas City Royals trade 3B Maikel Garcia, RHP James McArthur, and RHP L.P. Langevin to the Seattle Mariners for RHP Bryce Miller, LHP Jose A. Ferrer, and RHP Logan Evans.
A common fallacy among critics and internet commenters could be described as wishlisting: in other words, approaching an object or a piece of art wanting it to be about something other than what it is. The criticism of what’s absent in a work isn’t always wrong, particularly when it portends to be a universal treatise that leaves nothing out, or lays key arguments on the foundation of the unspoken assumptions. More often, however, this is simply a matter of the recipient’s personal taste, and their unwillingness/inability to meet the art on neutral ground.
Timing is also an issue. Unlike history, which languishes amid the panorama of the full view of time, people are trapped in the present, their view painfully ground-level. This is a particular curse for critics of sports, for whom the work is never officially done until the trophy gets hoisted. Criticizing a trade like this one is a little like reviewing the first draft of a novel; it’s particularly frustrating in the knowledge that many novels simply remain their first drafts. It is November, one is forced to tell themselves, and anything could still happen. And then, in a quieter voice, looking at the parties involved: Though not quite anything.
The Seattle Mariners and Kansas City Royals are both coming off disastrous 2026 seasons, falling 18 and 17 games shy of their respective PECOTA projected win totals. For each to climb back into optimistic territory, both clubs need to make multiple moves. Unfortunately, from our vantage here on November 19, we can only analyze the one. Making it worse is how familiar this trade feels to previous trades by both parties. For the Mariners, that recurring theme is investing trade capital into a single position-player upgrade and then effectively calling it an offseason (see: Donovan, Brendan). For the Royals, it’s a deck-shuffling trade that fills the glaring need of the moment by creating another in its wake (Angel Zerpa, Brady Singer two years ago).
It’s hard not to view this new deal in the lens of those deals, particularly since none of them are strictly independent of one another. And it’s not always easy to see the second step after this one, particularly for these two franchises. But one also has to resist the temptation to be that guy in the replies of a backup catcher signing announcement that smirks, “Raise the banner.”











![From [MLB on Fox]: Another look at the check-swing strikeout by Yandy Díaz that ended Game 2 of the World Series](https://preview.redd.it/uh4u0r563pxh1.jpeg?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=ef816fed7590738d8e06d01ee9444485885729f4)






English (US) ·
French (CA) ·