Language Selection

Get healthy now with MedBeds!
Click here to book your session

Protect your whole family with Orgo-Life® Quantum MedBed Energy Technology® devices.

Advertising by Adpathway

         

 Advertising by Adpathway

Ben Clemens FanGraphs Chat – 11/9/26

1 week ago 10

PROTECT YOUR DNA WITH QUANTUM TECHNOLOGY

Orgo-Life the new way to the future

  Advertising by Adpathway

Ben Clemens 11:00 AM

Hey everybody, welcome to the chat. I am just getting back from a dog walk and coffee run so need a few minutes to set up, my apologies. Please feel free to queue up some questions; we'll get started shortly.

Ben Clemens 11:02 AM

Alright, let's get going.

Topher 11:02 AM

With people bemoaning the lack of a good free agent class this year and with the talk of small market fans wanting their team to sign their young stars to extensions, do you think there is a way to marry the two ideals (wanting big free agencies with many stars and also having young stars signing extensions)?

Ben Clemens 11:02 AM

Oh, fun question. I think it's probably difficult with the existing pre-free-agency structure.

Ben Clemens 11:03 AM

Like, the NBA manages this somewhat, but the way they do is b/c their stars hit free agency pretty young and there's a collectively bargained limit on contract length.

Ben Clemens 11:03 AM

Also, I'm not even sure I want NBA free agency? It's not so fun that stars are changing teams so frequently, in my opinion.

Ben Clemens 11:05 AM

Truthfully, I think that this is not a huge problem. I don't think it's a big problem that this is a light free agency class overall. Baseball was fun this year, and being focused on how the baseball hot stove stuff will be less fun kind of misses the point. This winter is gonna be annoying, and bad for baseball fandom overall most likely – but for me, that's lockout-related, not anything about a good or bad free agency class. I like teams mostly staying together and a bit of mobility, and I think that if there are big issues with 'the market' in the offseason, it's more around how the news is spread out. I kind of like hte NBA's month-ish-long moratorium on transactions after the season ends (obvious exception for this year with the CBA expiration)

appayipyip 11:06 AM

kaima taira pitching to alejandro kirk would be among the most aesthetically pleasing batteries in baseball history and it should happen post haste

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member

It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:

✓Ad-free browsing

✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles

✓Historical & platoon projections

✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps

✓One-click data exports

✓Customizable player-page dashboards

✓Dark & Classic site modes

✓Weekly Members-only mailbag

✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review

✓Optional homepage photo removal

✓Gift articles to non-Members

✓Full postseason coverage

Ben Clemens 11:06 AM

I don't see how I could possibly argue with this statement.

Ben Clemens 11:07 AM

I am very excited for Taira, and I love Kirk's catching.

miratutti 11:07 AM

What are the realistic odds Acuna is not a Brave whenever the 2027 season begins?

Ben Clemens 11:09 AM

hmmmm…. this is a tough one for me to forecast from the outside. I am not super plugged in here and while I've seen a bit of scuttlebutt online, it doesn't make much sense to me. Like, the Braves are trying to compete, Acuna is 29 and probably their best outfield bat (the fact that it's only probably is worrisome, of course, but he's still good obv)

Ben Clemens 11:09 AM

I also don't think the return would be overwhelming. There's a reason I had him down in the 40s in trade value, far from his annual perch in the top 10

Ben Clemens 11:10 AM

So like…. this contending team is going to trade a nice contending-team combo of player and contract? What do we think they'd want for it? I just don't imagine it lining up well

Ben Clemens 11:10 AM

So my odds of him not being on the Braves? I dunno, 6%

oaktownblues 11:10 AM

Is there a general guideline for when a sac fly no longer helps a trailing team in terms of win probability? At a certain point depending on the deficit and the remaining innings, the run is less valuable than not making an out, but it's not clear to me when that point is for certain common deficits. E.g. If you're down by 4 in the 8th is a sac fly still helpful?

Ben Clemens 11:12 AM

So, down 4 bottom 8, man on third one out: home team 5.4% to win. Down 3 bottom 8, none on 2 out, home team 4.1% to win.

Ben Clemens 11:12 AM

Even going down 2 to down 1 is not good in that spot

Ben Clemens 11:12 AM

anyway you can kinda play around with it, but generally speaking when you're down more runs than there are innings left, sac flies aren't great.

drplantwrench 11:13 AM

when do you think the first flurry of signings occur?

Ben Clemens 11:13 AM

Please not this week. I'm tired.

Ben Clemens 11:13 AM

Um, next week, realistically. Beat Thanksgiving week, when I imagine there will be a slowdown.

eccentricatlfan 11:15 AM

Worth noting re: the Acuna question, AA has explicitly stated that while the team doesn’t give out no-trade clauses, the extensions essentially come with a handshake one.

Ben Clemens 11:15 AM

To be honest, I would not change my odds that much knowing that. THe odds are so low to start with that the situations where Acuna leaves probably disproportionately involve him wanting to leave. but good info nonetheless

miratutti 11:17 AM

22yo Catcher Q: who accumulates more WAR in 2027-28, Basallo or Bernal?

Ben Clemens 11:17 AM

I'd take Basallo in this tradeoff because I'm more sure of him being the starter. The Cardinals like Bernal, obviously, but they also like Crooks and Rodriguez, who we have with a 2028 ETA but who I could see with a late-27 arrival if they're comfortable with his defense, the bat is very impressive.

Ben Clemens 11:17 AM

Talent-wise, I think I might take Basallo anyway? But because of the PT situation I think he's more liekly to get a chance to accumulate

sliderinthedirt 11:17 AM

The Cubs are apparently already out on Skubal. His free agency is going to be interesting, I feel like he has a sketchier injury history than other pitchers of his caliber.

StuShea 11:17 AM

Thank you for chatting. How do the cubs thread this needle, rebuilding almost an entire pitching staff?

Ben Clemens 11:18 AM

I think that the injury history is not why the Cubs are out on Skubal. I think the issue here is that they need like 5 pitchers.

Ben Clemens 11:19 AM

I mean, maybe that's a slight exaggeration. But I imagine they are looking to sign 3-4 guys who they're at least okay with giving important innings to, and that makes it tough to also be splashing in the Skubal pool

Ben Clemens 11:21 AM

The good news for the Cubs here is that the class of pitchers that they seem comfortable with – largely because they've rostered many of them – is solid this year. Like, #4 starters, more or less. I imagine that you can get a decent amount of those types at competitive rates this year. It should be a team market for them, because that's the kind of guy you could imagine feeling a pinch if they wait until after the lockout and need to find a spot in a hurry.

Ben Clemens 11:21 AM

My plan would be to come in with a few targets you REALLY want. This part would have been accomplished during October, basically. And try to get 1 or 2 of those guys in the initial flurry. And then you can kinda float for a while, wait to see if there are bargains.

Ben Clemens 11:22 AM

The Brewers have accomplished this well for corner bats in the past. I imagine a similar strategy for role-player pitchers would work well this winter.

Alexander 11:22 AM

How long of a lockout do you expect that we will have? Do you have any thoughts about who caves first? Yes/No to salary cap?

Ben Clemens 11:24 AM

I'm trying not to get too prediction-heavy on this because I just don't think I have enough expertise in labor decisions to know. Particularly on the length. But my preliminary thoughts are that it feels to me like the players' proposal, while it has a lot of stuff that couldn't survive to a final state, could be altered enough to have enticements for owners that it stands a good chance of ending up as the framework for a deal.

Ben Clemens 11:25 AM

The specific parts that I think would persist are the redistribution of TV money and some kind of gentle floor that pays you extra for making the playoffs and whatnot

Ben Clemens 11:27 AM

Oh, and some expansion of the pre-arb bonus pool in exchange for mostly leaving the time to free agency alone, and also probably increasing the top band of the luxury tax not very quickly for some time.

Ben Clemens 11:28 AM

I mean, who knows. But in general, I have an easier time seeing some kind of compromise off of the player plan because owners have done pretty well in the existing environment, the ones with bad tv deals probably want revenue sharing there, and it's just generally easier to start from a 'like baseball today, but with x' blueprint than with one that blows everything up and starts fresh

samhorton 11:28 AM

How do you see the Mets approaching their staff assuming they miss on Skubal? I think Gray is a fit, maybe Bubic, Rasmussen/Detmers?

Ben Clemens 11:30 AM

Gray makes sense to me, but I feel like the real thing that I'm most certain of is that they want a second elite pitcher to pair with McLean. It seems like that was at least the concept in the Peralta trade. So whether it's Skubal or Gray, or Rasmussen (v unlikely to me), I think they will put a lot of focus on a guy who can be excellent this year. Like, I am into Trevor Rogers, there's a reason I had him as the second pitcher on my top 50 list, but I don't think that's the kind of bet the Mets are looking to make right now. I see them looking more for current elite level rather than 'this guy is the best value bet to explode into an elite starter for years to come'

wheelhouse 11:31 AM

Michael Massey for Will Warren, who says no

Ben Clemens 11:33 AM

Presumably the Yankees? I'm not really in on Massey, to me he's just a second division regular or perhaps a role player on a playoff team. Whereas Warren has two more years til FA and is a pitcher who has thrown 150 innings with reasaonble ERA's in two straight years

appayipyip 11:33 AM

what if skubal decides he wants to spend a year living and working abroad and signs with the Yomiuri Giants what then

Ben Clemens 11:33 AM

Well, that'd be kind of amazing? Man, I know elite athletes are just not wired like I am and thus trying to put myself in their shoes doesn't work, but I'd be very tempted to try something like this

wheelhouse 11:33 AM

Do you think Minnesota will look to trade Royce Lewis

Ben Clemens 11:35 AM

I mean, try to? Sure. But presumably the bid is 'PTBNL' to start. He's Arb2, he has an 85 wRC+ in his last two seasons comprising nearly 1000 PA, and he's injury prone

wheelhouse 11:35 AM

The appeal to Massey is that he’s a very good defender and a lefty hitter with a career >25% Pull-AIR rate. I think he has 20 HR potential in a better park for him

Ben Clemens 11:37 AM

Yeah eh…. could be true. Don't think the perception is that high, though I could be wrong. I just believe that there are a lot of guys with numbers like that, and most of them don't become great. Whereas there aren't as many guys with innings numbers like Warren's and teams seem to be valuing them very highly.

drplantwrench 11:37 AM

baseball must be the best for journeyman, because i would do anything to drop everything and move to japan

Ben Clemens 11:37 AM

Haha right? I mean, again we are probably not mentally built like your average professoinal athlete

Ben Clemens 11:38 AM

but for me, making a good amount of money (in the grand scheme of things) without being particularly well-known, and getting to travel the world while doing it? Yes please.

Patrick Burke 11:38 AM

What would a package to acquire Steven Kwan look like? Where are possible fits for him?

Ben Clemens 11:39 AM

So, one year of Kwan, for low 8 figures. I would have ballparked like 10.5m, MLBTR's estimate is at 11.3

Ben Clemens 11:41 AM

My rough mental model here is that puts him around a 50 FV bat in terms of surplus value? Give or take. And that feels about right to me – top 100 prospect for a year of a very good corner bat.

Ben Clemens 11:42 AM

Looking through some past trades for a comp

Ben Clemens 11:44 AM

Okay, doing that live was a little more than I could manage. But something along the lines of a far-off but toolsy outfielder makes sense to me, and I do think the Guardians are gonig to be open to trading him.

robert james 11:44 AM

I once met a journeyman MiLB reliever who ended up going to Japan, he was married with young kids and he talked about how moving to Japan was a dream- instead of bouncing from like Indianapolis and Shreveport he made 7 figures, the team rented him a nice house, the family could stay together, etc. He said that no one could understand why he left because all his friends/family/casual acquaintances considered it some massive stepdown. It was interesting

Ben Clemens 11:44 AM

Yeah, that makes total sense to me (both how he felt and how friends might not agree)

bosoxforlife 11:44 AM

In this era of TTO baseball it was enjoyable to see the 2 teams with the highest batting average playing in the World Series. The Brewers led baseball in the much maligned statistic of batting average and ,while .258 is historically very low, the Brewers did not field a regular with an average under .230 and also were second in walks received. This is a combination that underscores the reason the Brewers were second in runs scored and could be a precursor to an approach that has been abandoned in recent years.

Ben Clemens 11:45 AM

I'm skeptical because it seems hard! I agree that the Brewers, in particular, have worked out a great way to score runs via an OBP-first view rather than a slug-first view

Ben Clemens 11:46 AM

The Rays were a meaningfully worse offense than the Brewers, and I don't think their model was planned so much as happened upon

Ben Clemens 11:46 AM

But I think that a lot of teams would love to play like the Brewers if they could

Ben Clemens 11:47 AM

It's definitely kind of funny that the Brewers are the scrappy underdog team, no doubt, Sal Frelick is tiny, etc., but it's also kind of just a squad of high draft picks?

Ben Clemens 11:48 AM

Frelick was a first rounder, Mitchell was a first rounder, Turang was a first rounder, Chourio got about 2 million in IFA, you get the idea.

Ben Clemens 11:49 AM

Like, yes, you should play like the Brewers if you can. But that is tough! You gotta draft and develop well

wheelhouse 11:50 AM

Luis Garcia Jr. for Lars Nootbaar, which side has to add to get it done

Ben Clemens 11:50 AM

I'm probably the wrong person to answer becuase I'm a big Nootbaar fan. But I could see both sides agreeing to this deal without much added either way, maybe Arizona kicks in small? And it does seem like it would work well for both.

Patrick Burke 11:53 AM

Do posted players HAVE to sign before Dec 2? I keep seeing that said. If my memory is correct, didn't Seiya Suzuki wait until after the lockout to sign?

Ben Clemens 11:54 AM

so maybe they will at the last minute? But I haven't seen any news around that.

robert james 11:54 AM

Re: The Brewers, they're great and I know we all have tiny attention spans these days, but I keep reminding my buddy that up until a month ago the Brewers were famous for NOT being able to win the title. Not just the franchise, this specific Brewers team was seen as a "regular season" thing that couldn't possibly win a WS. And now that they have their a dynasty that will reign for 1000 years that every team should mimic. Again, they're great, but we all need to take a breath

Ben Clemens 11:54 AM

Haha yeah, well, that's just the way sports are. Whatever worked most recently becomes very intriguing

Ben Clemens 11:55 AM

To be fair, though, I don't think that this year's Brewers were a perfect match for previous years. One thing that they had going for them this year is that they've always been high-floor but they added a good amount of high ceiling, between Chourio and Miz both taking big steps forward and Turang solidifying his gains

Ben Clemens 11:56 AM

So it's a mixture of the two. I think that a good lesson you could take from the Brewers is that it's possible to build a team that scores a lot of runs via having a ton of athletic dudes on base. But that doesn't absolve you from still needing some top end talent to have the best shot at the whole ball of yarn.

Ben Clemens 11:56 AM

And then also, yes, never read too much into one playoff run

bosoxforlife 11:57 AM

Does Stanton ever play another game for the Yankees and if he does, where do Rice and Garcia Jr. play

Ben Clemens 11:57 AM

I think he will. And I think I agree with Wheelhouse's view that Garcia will play in some other city to make it work.

bosoxforlife 11:57 AM

Frelick is the type of player I am thinking of. Maybe teams will draft more players of that ilk. Pratt is certainly not a power hitter either and they saw enough to give him along term deal before he ever played a game.

Ben Clemens 11:58 AM

Yeah. I don't really agree with your point on Pratt, b/c the long term deal there certainly felt like it was about defense, but hitting on guys like Frelick is definitely a good plan. The truth is, it's not like teams never try this. Nick Madrigal was one of my great misses as an evaluator

Ben Clemens 11:58 AM

But getting better at selecting these kinds of skills, and prizing them enough to take some risks on them? I agree this is a good plan.

Ben Clemens 11:58 AM

Heck, the A's tried this with Kyler Murray, right?

mr. burrito 11:59 AM

OK, this is crazy, but… de Paula to the Braves for Acuna… the dodgers trade off/give away Teo (sad face emoji here) and install Acuna in LF… ? am i the little person on fantasy island, or does this make some kind of weird sense?

Ben Clemens 12:01 PM

I guess I could see this for the Braves. But I'm not sure I see it for the Dodgers. It's subtracting two guys to add one, and if I'm them, I don't like the idea of getting rid of one of my best prospects and yet still feeling like the team is old and the roster is inflexible.

g4 12:01 PM

Also RE the recipe for Brew Crew success: Run prevention > Run scoring

Ben Clemens 12:01 PM

Haha well yes, this goes unsaid but they allowed 2.5 runs per game in the playoffs.

Ben Clemens 12:02 PM

run prevention tends to win

Ben Clemens 12:02 PM

look what their run prevention squad did to the Rays' small ball approach. Jeez.

bosoxforlife 12:02 PM

With regards to the Brewers approach, I am of the firm belief that being in contention for a long period of time is the true measure of success. This year is most certainly not some fluke. Winning in baseball's tournament is nice but not a necessary ingredient for measuring excellence.

Ben Clemens 12:03 PM

That's likely true. But well…. you gotta win sometime. Fans want you to win sometime. I wish that regular season excellence were valued more. But fans really crave that trophy, and I think that matters for success as a result. I really like the soccer structure of like, some playoffs, but also the playoffs and regular season are fundamentally disconnected and there are winners of both.

wheelhouse 12:03 PM

Okay one more and I’m done: Heliot Ramos for Bryson Stott

Ben Clemens 12:05 PM

I'm surely the wrong person to ask on this one because I see Ramos as having very little value. Righty bat, no defensive value, squarely in the offensive dead zone where it's not like you have to try that hard to find a similar level of offense

Ben Clemens 12:06 PM

Whereas Stott feels like a lite version of Kwan, you get an above average regular (I value Kwan's contributions more highly b/c there's more offense to it, I feel like Stott's baserunning/defense value makes his WAR shinier than his contributions are actually valuable to teams looking to build their roster)

Ben Clemens 12:06 PM

So if I'm the Phillies trading Stott, I want an interesting prospect, not a guy I think I might be able to get on waivers

Ben Clemens 12:06 PM

but like… I watched a lot of Ramos's bad defense over the years and I recognize that might make me a little worse at evaluating him

Ben Clemens 12:08 PM

Okay, quick speed round and then I'm going to go have leftover pizza for lunch.

krob4385 12:08 PM

How many games do you reckon we miss next year?

Ben Clemens 12:09 PM

I'm still on zero as median outcome.

SPArn 12:09 PM

The NBA is also often derided as an "offseason league" and I really think it would be a shame if baseball turned into that too

Ben Clemens 12:09 PM

agreed. I like the regular season in baseball a lot. Basketball's is so boring.

SPArn 12:09 PM

Do you have a personal favorite unheralded free agent that couldn't crack even your top 50?

Ben Clemens 12:09 PM

Joe Jimenez. Tried pretty hard to rationalize getting him on there but like…. c'mon

drplantwrench 12:10 PM

do you think the AL West will be as stinky as it has been the last two years?

Ben Clemens 12:10 PM

probably not quite that bad, but I think the Astros are probably in a subtraction mode so it's not like it's going to be a great division. Kinda depends on how aggresive Kroenke is, but my base case is that he's not gonna try to turn the team around suddenly in FA

Three Finger Reinhardt 12:10 PM

Your dog: what's its breed and name?

Ben Clemens 12:11 PM

i read this as a phishing question for a while but then I realized that there are so many pictures and posts about her online that I've made in the past that it's fine. Ruby is, I dunno, a mutt? Part pitty, part some kind of retriever.

miratutti 12:11 PM

Did the Brewers just create a million Andy Ashby's?

Ben Clemens 12:11 PM

If so, well, that seems like a good plan. Gl, other teams.

Ben Clemens 12:12 PM

not the best ashby you could have created, but still excellent

Bud Smith 12:12 PM

More of a programming question than a Ben question, but is it possible to keep the chat panel on the sidebar updated with the chats that are actually expected to happen that week, or an indication when they are on hiatus and expected to miss a week or more? Some of the ones listed there haven't actually happened in over a month

Ben Clemens 12:12 PM

Yeah, I"ll run that up the flagpole, but we're working on this specific thing already, and you can see the 'on hiatus til after ws' on Roster Resource chat. It's something we plan to improve.

fincampbell05 12:12 PM

Roman Anthony, Franklin Arias, Jake Bennett, Justin Gonzales for Elly De La Cruz. Is it enough?

Ben Clemens 12:13 PM

Completely missed this in the queue but I think that would be more than enough? But appropriately splashy, I dno't think Arias plus spare change is close, so this is closer to what would make sense in my head. I don't really think Elly is getting traded though.

Ben Clemens 12:13 PM

On that note, I'm gonna call it a day. Thanks for a shocking number of baseball questions today, you guys never tire. Love it. Have a great week.

Read Entire Article

         

        

HOW TO FIGHT BACK WITH THE 5G  

Protect your whole family with Quantum Orgo-Life® devices

  Advertising by Adpathway